Studio: Scream Factory
Release Date: 12/10/2024
Rating: R
Film Grade: C-
The Story: After a short visit with Grandpa, little Billy Chapman and his family stop to help a stranded “Santa” whose car has broken down. This is no ordinary jolly old man, though, as he was fleeing after having robbed a liquor store. The faux St. Nick assaults, brutalizes, and kills Billy’s parents, leaving him and his younger brother to be raised by nuns at a depressingly stern orphanage.
Influenced by earlier tales of a Santa that punished anyone who’s been naughty, Billy is haunted and forever scarred by the events of that horrible night. At the age of 18, Billy gets his first job at a local toy store that needs some additional help over the upcoming Yuletide season. How an adult Billy confronts his repressed feelings about that jolly old elf will change things forever for the sleepy, small community.
My Take: Developed during the advent of 80’s slasher movies, the film settled on another holiday as a hook for the title and concept. Images of a terrorizing Santa were judged too negatively for a general audience back then and Tri-Star ended up pulling it from theaters after its first week. It wasn’t until its release on home video that the movie started to find its audience. Since then, it’s attained a level of cult status, with some families considering it their holiday movie of choice (take that, Die Hard!).
The movie is best appreciated by those looking for a nostalgic view of those times. I didn’t catch it during its original theatrical release and never picked up the VHS, so this was my first viewing of it, so I can’t look at it through those glasses. The production seems schizophrenic at times, likely due to the differing visions of the original development team and the studio. In the extras, the screenplay writer mentions that he felt it was a comedy, but it doesn’t feel like this was ever communicated to the director. There aren’t many lines that could be considered funny, and those that are, miss their mark.
The directing choice is an odd one with Charles E. Sellier Jr. taking the reins. Best known for writing the original Grizzly Adams novel and creating the subsequent TV show, his other works include such titles as In Search of Noah’s Ark and Hanger 18, as well as numerous faith-based movies and TV shows and specials. He did have a strong track record for working with a low budget, and that may have been the deciding factor in his hiring. From listening to the extras, he didn’t have much influence on the actors’ performances, preferring more of a hands-off approach.
This was most apparent with the role of the adult Billy, played by Robert Brian Wilson in his debut role. While physically fitting, Wilson’s lack of training is apparent in how Billy lacks the dimensionality for what is needed in the character. His performance was aided by Lilyan Chauvin, who portrays the stern and unyielding Mother Superior, head of the orphanage. In addition to being a talented French actress, she was also a drama coach offering Wilson valuable advice on the set. The film’s best performance is by Britt Leach, as Mr. Sims, affable owner of the toy store. He gives Sims a cynical edge to the season, as it’s both the busiest and most profitable time of the year. For scream queen fans, it’s worth mentioning that Linnea Quigley has a role in the movie, doing what she’s most famous for, if you know what I mean.
Narratively, the film jumps around in an almost haphazard way. While there is a tangible connection between the deranged Santa and some of his victims, others appear completely random, giving the plot an unnecessarily disjointed feel. They seem to only serve as pawns in murder segment to murder segment, rather than part of a cohesive progression. Other elements are added that don’t lead anywhere. The incorporation and character of Grandpa, for example, is only added as a plot point and feels tacked on. That segment could have been aided by reframing it and adding a bit of mystery by not including the direct interaction between him and Billy.
One of the development team’s goals was to incorporate Christmastime trappings into the story, and while they used some of those elements, there were plenty of missed opportunities. Only a handful of kills use themed props, with others settling for the mundane, which missed an opportunity for the movie to differentiate itself from all of the other entries in the genre.
Where it does work, it works well, such as a set of nutcrackers staring onward, with mouths agape after witnessing one of the murders. It’s an unexpected and clever touch that takes advantage of the setting’s decorations. Some of the earliest segments dealing with the unfortunate commercial cynicism that is tied to today’s build up and observation of the holiday, are another example. There are also some nice touches with the bright-eyed, adorably innocent young Billy, prior to his fateful night, contrasted later with his strict upbringing at the orphanage. The movie would have been elevated by concentrating on more of those aspects rather than the shallow kills.
Visuals: The 4K transfer offers a fantastic presentation of the movie, looking clean but with grain still present. Much of this was shot at night, but even dark scenes are clear and not muddy. The depressingly utilitarian look of the orphanage adds to Billy’s backstory, as does the vintage wood paneling of one of the houses visited by the murderous St. Nick. Those are a nod to the on-location filming that was used for the movie, rather than a typical movie set. The HDR improvement is evident on some scenes, such as cloudy skies and mountaintop snow, and there is more detail compared to the HD disc, even if it’s no slouch on its own. The only nitpick here are the added scenes on the uncut Blu-ray disc, which are presented in standard definition and disrupt the flow of the film. They don’t add much to the story, so while the curious might want to check them out, I’d stick with the theatrical version.
Audio: The movie is presented with its original mono soundtrack sent to the left and right channels. I found the Auro upmixer produced a good presentation, giving the mix a little more fullness than just using left and right speakers. The musical score was written by prolific composer Perry Botkin Jr. and features a number of different elements. In addition to some traditional tunes, there are some seasonal pop songs with words by Morgan Ames, which are reminiscent of the generic background music that might be heard while shopping at a mall. The rest of the soundtrack features a range of electronic music that fits well in the period without sounding derivative, with harsh bells, lyric piano, and the occasional cacophony of strings. Dialog is easily understandable throughout.
Special Features: All of the extras are where this set really shines. There are a ton of interviews and commentaries for fans to watch and listen to, adding an unusual amount of depth for such a feature. It’s fascinating to hear the different viewpoints of the people involved, creating an almost Rashomon-style variety of perspectives depending on who one listens to. Although I gave the movie a C- rating, the variety of commentaries are on an A level.
DISC ONE (4K UHD – THEATRICAL VERSION) NEW 4K Transfer from the Original Camera Negative Presented in Dolby Vision:
- NEW Audio Commentary with Author Amanda Reyes and The Hysteria Continues Podcast
DISC TWO (BLU-RAY – THEATRICAL VERSION) NEW 4K Transfer from the Original Camera Negative:
- NEW Audio Commentary with Author Amanda Reyes and The Hysteria Continues Podcast
- NEW "The Night He Came Home... For Christmas: Creating Silent Night, Deadly Night" – An Interview with Producer Scott Schneid
- NEW "In Search of Charles Sellier Jr: Remembering the Director" – An Interview with Editor Michael Spence
- NEW "Naughty or Nice: 40 Years of Silent Night, Deadly Night" – An Interview the Producers Scott Schneid and Dennis Whitehead About the Longevity of the Film
DISC THREE (BLU-RAY – UNRATED VERSION) NEW 4K Transfer from The Original Camera Negative with Standard Definition Inserts:
- Audio Commentary with Actor Robert Brian Wilson and Co-Executive Producer Scott J. Schneid
- Audio Commentary with Writer Michael Hickey, Composer Perry Boykin, Producer Scott J. Schneid, and Unit Director Michael Spence
- “Slay Bells Ring: The Story of Silent Night, Deadly Night” – Featuring Interviews with Writer Michael Hickey, Co-Executive Producers Scott J. Schneid and Dennis Whitehead, Editor/Second Unit Director Michael Spence, Composer Perry Botkin, and Actor Robert Brian Wilson
- “Oh Deer!” – An Interview with Actor Linnea Quigley
- Christmas In July – Silent Night, Deadly Night Locations – Then and Now
- Audio Interview with Director Charles E. Sellier, Jr. From Deadpit Radio (Extended Version)
- “Santa’s Stocking Of Outrage”
- Poster and Still Gallery
- R-Rated Theatrical Trailer & Japanese VHS Trailer
- TV Spots
- Radio Spot
Final Verdict: I felt like an outsider looking in with this movie. Not having seen it when it first came out or with the subsequent releases, there’s a nostalgia factor that I couldn’t relate to. That the movie has developed a cult following since its release shows that there is an audience for it that appreciates the mix of cheery holiday traditions with a bloody, murderous rampage.
Scream Factory has put together a delightful package for true fans of the movie. The extras were absolutely fascinating to me, going over the origins of the films, to the actual production, filled with interesting stories about how this group of newcomers were ushered into the business and how their deal evolved. The audio interview with the director adds an additional dimension, as he not only discusses this effort, but his other work and the way his company developed over the years.
It's recommended for those that like this type of movie and may have a soft spot for it, as the presentation is as true to the source material as one could ever expect. I’ll add a secondary recommendation for those interested in how a small movie like this was made four decades ago. That was the unexpected highlight of the package for me.
Fun Quote: “What about you, boy? You been good all year? If you see Santa Claus tonight, you better run, boy. You better run for your life!”
I couldn’t find a trailer for the new release, but here’s an earlier version that will give you a good feel for the movie:
https://youtu.be/AwiK-8utQ74?list=PLBrrfZs-ew7MfIiT3rkxijU5CxMmE5tw-My Review System:JVC DLA-RS3100 4K Ultra High-Definition Front Projector
Elite Screens Sable Frame B2 117” Width with Infinitely Variable Height
Monolith by Monoprice HTP-1 16 Channel Processor with Dirac Live
Monolith by Monoprice 7x200 Watts Amp
Monolith by Monoprice 3x200 Watts + 6x100 Watts Amp
JBL Studio 590 for Left, Center, Right, Wides, and Rears
JBL Studio 580 for Side Surrounds
JBL Studio SCS 8 for Tops
JTR Captivator 1400 Subwoofer X 4
Panasonic DP-UB420 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Player
NVIDIA Shield Android TV - 4K
Xbox One X
HTPC Running madVR (work in progress)
Remote: URC MX-780
Mini DSP 2X4 HD controlling all subwoofers
APC S15 Power Conditioner with Battery Backup
0 Replies
1148 Views