Craig,You could definitely benefit from a Mini-DSP (or two given how many subs you have). My suspicion is you're probably losing some output at some frequencies because of the way the waves are moving through the room. One of these days I'll have to come over with REW and run some sweeps
Maybe, but I'd need a lot more subwoofer cables. Mike also pointed out that the Mini-DSP would only affect the bass at the main listening position - which I really don't have. I have 8+ seats over 16'.
It depends on your goal. You can optimize bass for one seat or you can optimize bass for multiple seats, but you can't do both.
I have treatments as well, but after using a MiniDSP, the bass response is better for all of the seats in the room. I've compared before and after frequency sweeps in all of my listening positions and there's improvement in every case, although the "money seat" still has the best sound since that's the seat that all of the measurements/changes are done with in mind.
I have panels on the ceiling above my screen and on the rear wall. I would do more but my room is complicated.
My room is fairly complicated too. So far though the bass is sounding much more even across all seats, so I must be on the right track.
Panels help a ton--I have them employed as well. What changed was overall sub output, which increased a lot, especially during high intensity LFE films--way more headroom if the subs are working in tandem instead of independently. When installing your subs, did you gain match them first? This requires placing a piece of tape on the floor to mark the front of the woofer and then running a 50 or 60Hz tone through your AVR/Pre-pro. If you can, turn off your main speakers and only have your sub playing. Measure the value at a single point in the room (center seat). Then take sub #2 and measure the same value using the volume knob on the sub to match that sub to the first. Do this with all of your subs.This takes the overall room boost out based on placement. Once completed, put all their subwoofers in their respective positions. If you aren't going to use a MiniDSP, then at this point set the volume level in your pre/pro using a calibration disc or test tone from your gear. The reason you want to set them up this way is to ensure that one subwoofer isn't overtaking the room with its greater output or location. This made a big difference in my room even before employing the MiniDSP and EQ.