My wife & I were also big GoT fans - she didn't have quite as much of an issue as me with the decline in writing & characterization quality in the last couple of season, though. We've gone through the series a couple of times (well, most of it for me... I couldn't stand to watch the final season another time it was so terribly written compare to the first 5-6) so were looking forward to seeing how HotD came out. The first season was hard to follow in part due to the shifting cast members and timelines, where some characters changed actors while others didn't. The story wasn't quite as cohesive either. Maybe it would benefit more than most TV seasons from a rewatch. IMO it wasn't up to the quality of GoT S1. S2 however, seemed much more cohesive and flowed better, and we really enjoyed it. Thinking it was also 10 episodes but not checking, we were stunned at the end of Ep 8 to find that was IT. That's the sign of a strong season though - we wanted MORE!
Greetings,Nice review Dave!