If you read my posts, you'll see that it is recommended to use V11 if you can.So he can do anything he wants with V11, color with the i1pro2, gamma with the Spyder 5, whatever.It's only with V12 that I'm saying that running a color only with the i1pro2 can produce results inferior to what can be obtained with V11. The issue with V12 might not be only with the Spyder X.At least that's what I observe here.
I have always had a dilemma on this: since grey scale is anyway impacted by color calibration, which one do you recommend to autocalibrate first, gamma or color?Also, is gamma autocalibration performed separately on the three primary colors? I think so and this can have an implication on the answer to the above question.
Sure, I provided the suggestion based on your post.
In that case your suggestion doesn't make sense.
I can do a color autocal with my I1pro2
there might be some issues with the i1pro2 in V12 as well
In theory, it shouldn't make any difference which one you do first. In practice, I think color first would be better, but I haven't confirmed this and that's one of the things I'd like to rule out in my upcoming V11/V12 comparison.Yes, gamma autocal is performed separately on the three primary colors, as can be seen during the autocal process. Otherwise, the accuracy of the spyder on white/grey would be an issue and it doesn't seem to be the case.
So, even though spyderx is inaccurate on white, is it accurate enough on R/G/B?
1) I checked the ranges for color autocal, and they are the same as before: 0 to -3, -4 to -7, -8 to -11, -12 to -15. However, there is a significant and increasing difference in the RGB balance as you close the iris down until the next range starts, so I would advise to calibrate the iris setting that you actually use in each range for maximum accuracy.
Out of interest - in what direction? Does it get yellower by any chance?
I ran a few color autocal with my i1pro2 yesterday and I can confirm two things:1) I checked the ranges for color autocal, and they are the same as before: 0 to -3, -4 to -7, -8 to -11, -12 to -15. However, there is a significant and increasing difference in the RGB balance as you close the iris down until the next range starts
I ran a few color autocal with my i1pro2 yesterday and I can confirm two things:1) I checked the ranges for color autocal, and they are the same as before: 0 to -3, -4 to -7, -8 to -11, -12 to -15. However, there is a significant and increasing difference in the RGB balance as you close the iris down until the next range starts, so I would advise to calibrate the iris setting that you actually use in each range for maximum accuracy. For example, I calibrated at 0, -5 and -9 to calibrate the three settings that I am most likely to use in HDR.
Hi Manni, could you clarify please? What means "they are the same as before"? Before to autocal? Means autocal not changed color gamut? Mean not changed white point? Means for example that in the first range 0 to -3 for a total of four autocal operation and nothing (what?) changed but the RGB change was significant? Which has been your methodology for check and the target?